rbutr is primarily a browser plugin; we'd love you to register and join us.
That way, you'll be notified of rbutls as you view the source page, you'll be able to add rbutls to our system, and you'll be able to vote and subscribe to tags.

rbutd

 

28 rbutls

Carman - Organic Systems Journal Vol.8 No.1 (2013)
organic-systems.org/journal/81/abstracts/8106.html
0 28


3 0 0.0021
From ‘I smell a rat’ to ‘when pigs fly’, bad science makes its rounds | Cami Ryan
doccamiryan.wordpress.com/2013/06/12/from-i-smell-a-rat-to-when-pigs-f..
Summary of rebuttals of the original paper
13 1

Link by Joon

3 0 0.0021
Detailed comment on Carman et al (2013): study design and conduct
foodstandards.gov.au/consumer/gmfood/Pages/Detailed-commentary-.aspx#
This analysis by the food safety agency of Australia and New Zealand thoroughly discredits the Carman--Vlieger pig study on scientific grounds.
1 0

GMO
Link by rlobb
D
2 0 0.0011
Response to a feeding study in pigs by Carman et al
foodstandards.gov.au/consumer/gmfood/Pages/Response-to-Dr-Carman%27s-s..
Food safety agency responds to the Carman pig study.
4 0

Link by MaryM

1 0 0.0001
The evidence of GMO harm in pig study is pretty flimsy – Control Freaks
weedcontrolfreaks.com/2013/06/gmo-pig/
Original paper has severe issues with the statistics techniques that were used, suggesting lack of competence (if not bias)
19 1

Link by Joon

1 0 0.0001
GM pig feed and stomach inflammation | Science Media Centre
sciencemediacentre.org/gm-pig-feed-and-stomach-inflammation/
Science Media Centre summarizes claims and issues.
15 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
An investigation into the latest study on transgenic food and pigs | frozenink.net
frozenink.net/2013/06/an-investigation-into-the-latest-study-on-transg..
In short, this study is a mini Seralini – and considering how closely Carman is linked to Seralini, it’s quite possible that he helped with this trainwreck of a study.
13 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Something Smells, and It’s Not the Pigs | Beyond the Rows
monsantoblog.com/2013/06/13/something-smells-and-its-not-the-pigs/
These products are more rigorously tested than any other food product available today
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Scientists say pigs hurt by genetically modified food - but they were wrong | Your Doctor's Orders
yourdoctorsorders.com/2013/06/pigs-and-gmo/
Pigs that eat genetically modified foods have less inflammation than pigs that eat normal- the opposite of what the news reported
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Canadian experts convinced GMO swine feed study is deeply flawed - Let's Talk Farm Animals
letstalkfarmanimals.ca/2013/06/13/canadian-experts-convinced-gmo-swine..
Canadian animal health specialists are among the experts around the world denouncing a recent study suggesting animals are harmed by eating GM crops.
14 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Lack of care when choosing grains invalidates pig feeding study « Biology Fortified, Inc.
biofortified.org/2013/06/pig-feeding-study-gmo/
Lack of assessment of the feed components is a major and crucial flaw in this work.
16 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Full Statement by Professor Robert Friendship, University of Guelph on Study by Carman et al on Feeding of Genetically Modified Corn and Soybeans to Pigs | Terry Daynard's Blog
tdaynard.com/2013/06/14/full-statement-by-professor-robert-friendship-..
Swine health professor says the inflammation measurement was worthless.
16 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
The New Pig Study Gets An “F” In Science | SLEUTH 4 HEALTH
sleuth4health.wordpress.com/2013/06/13/the-new-pig-study-gets-an-f-in-..
The New Pig Study Gets An F€ In Science
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
New GMO study with pigs is “hogwash” - Newsroom - Ag Professional
agprofessional.com/news/New-GMO-study-with-pigs-is-hogwash-211368721.h..

12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Tamar Haspel: GM Feed, Pigs, and Stomach Inflammation: Smoking Gun?
huffingtonpost.com/tamar-haspel/gm-feed-pigs-stomach-inflammation_b_34..
Read the paper, look at the data, and what you come away with is hard evidence that factory farming is a terrible way to raise pigs.
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Study shows GMO feed improves liver health in pigs! — Jayson Lusk
jaysonlusk.com/blog/2013/6/13/study-shows-gmo-feed-improves-liver-heal..
What you'll find is, by and large, a fishing expedition. Just by chance, the authors would expect to find one or two significant differences and that's exactly what they found
15 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
expert reaction to new study on GM pig feed and stomach inflammation | Science Media Centre
sciencemediacentre.org/expert-reaction-to-new-study-on-gm-pig-feed-and..
It does not look like a convincing adverse effect as it was a minor incidental finding
14 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Quantum Forest
quantumforest.com/
Points out basic errors in mathematical analysis of data
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
PLOS ONE: Effects of Feeding Bt MON810 Maize to Pigs for 110 Days on Peripheral Immune Response and Digestive Fate of the cry1Ab Gene and Truncated Bt Toxin
plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0036141
Shows that mechanism suggested by Carman and Vlieger does not actually occur
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
PLOS ONE: The Effect of Feeding Bt MON810 Maize to Pigs for 110 Days on Intestinal Microbiota
plosone.org/article/info:doi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0033668
Study shows that GM maize had no impact on intestinal microbiota of pigs, refuting Carman-Vlieger paper.
12 0

Link by Shane
D
1 0 0.0001
Bad science about GMOs: It reminds me of the antivaccine movement (revisited) – Respectful Insolence
scienceblogs.com/insolence/2013/06/17/bad-science-about-gmos-it-remind..

15 0

Link by tscanlon

1 0 0.0001
New study shows how not to use statistics - Inexact Change
inexactchange.org/blog/2013/06/19/gmo-pig-study/
Exploration of the statistical choices of the pig stomach inflammation paper.
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Professor Parrott: GMO reports that fail
parrottlab.uga.edu/ProfParrott/pigs2013.html
A science professor grades this paper, gives it an "F".
12 0

Link by Shane

1 0 0.0001
Illumination: When the Science Sucks, You Can Have it Both Ways!
kfolta.blogspot.com/2013/06/when-science-sucks-you-can-have-it-both.ht..
When the Science Sucks, You Can Have it Both Ways!
13 0

Link by Shane
D
1 0 0.0001
You Can Put Lipstick On A Pig (Study), But It Still Stinks - Forbes
forbes.com/sites/henrymiller/2013/07/17/you-can-put-lipstick-on-a-pig-..
Claims of the GMO feed study are examined and found lacking.
1 0

Link by MaryM

1 0 0.0001
Mark Lynas » GMO pigs study – more junk science
marklynas.org:80/2013/06/gmo-pigs-study-more-junk-science/
Original study engages in statistical fishing, biased presentation, poor animal husbandry, plus authors have a conflict of interest.
15 2

Link by Joon
D
1 0 0.0001
Mark Lynas » GMO pigs study – more junk science
marklynas.org/2013/06/gmo-pigs-study-more-junk-science/
Directly rebuts the study and the points that it raises.
3 0

Link by Salius

1 0 0.0001
GMO Pundit a.k.a. David Tribe: Pigs in the real world -- feed them different diets, measure many health parameters, some will show differences -- but what does it all mean?
gmopundit.blogspot.com/2013/06/pigs-in-real-world-feed-them-different...
Original study lacks hypothesis, engages in fishing for data, uses poor statistics, disregards role of nutrition and differences in feed
16 1

Link by Joon

1 0 0.0001
Pollan and Bittman, the Morano and Milloy of GMO anti-science – denialism blog
scienceblogs.com/denialism/2013/06/12/pollan-and-bittman-the-morano-an..
An MD evaluates the claims of the paper and finds the support lacking.
14 0

Link by Shane

Tweets sharing the rbutd page...

Loading twitter feed.
privacy policy  |  faq  |  screenshots  |  contact  |  how you can help